How do you cook frozen Butterball turkey burgers in the oven?

Butterball turkey burgers are a popular choice for people who seek to enjoy a delicious burger without the harmful effects of red meat. These burgers are readily available in many stores in frozen form, which makes them convenient to purchase and store. However, many people may not know how to cook them properly without compromising their quality. In this article, we will explore how to cook frozen Butterball turkey burgers in the oven.

Preparing to Cook Frozen Butterball Turkey Burgers in the Oven

The first step in preparing to cook frozen Butterball turkey burgers is to thaw them properly. Thawing allows the burger’s inside temperature and outside temperature to balance each other and ensures even cooking throughout.

The best way to thaw your frozen turkey burgers is by placing them in the refrigerator for 24 hours before cooking. This method is safe and doesn’t compromise the taste or texture of your burger.

If you want to save time, you could use the microwave’s defrost function; however, it would be best if you were careful not to cook any parts of the patties during this process.

It’s essential not to attempt cooking your Butterball turkey burgers directly from their frozen state because this can cause uneven cooking or even undercooked centers that can lead to foodborne illness.

Materials Required for Cooking

Apart from your frozen Butterball turkey burgers, here are some other materials you will need:

  • Baking Sheet
  • Parchment Paper
  • Small Dish For Glaze (Optional)
  • Digital Thermometer (Optional)

The glaze dish is entirely optional for those that wish t add sauce or glaze elements as they desire for personal preference/taste.

Oven Settings for Cooking Frozen Butterball Turkey Burgers

Determining what oven settings work best depends on your preference and/or busy schedule. Regardless of how you choose though, oven setting consistency is crucial when making anything so that an ideal outcome will happen to make sure that both patties cook evenly, retaining all the moisture and flavors.

The ideal temperature for cooking Butterball turkey burgers falls between 350°F and 375°F. At this temperature, actively defrosting patties can take around 27 minutes and already thawed – under half an hour to complete the baking process. And remember – these times will vary by your oven’s consistency as well, so always check in on them during the process.

The Steps Involved in Cooking Frozen Turkey Burgers

  1. Remove your pre-thawed Butterball turkey burgers from the fridge, wait a while until they are at room temperature.
  2. While waiting at room temperature, prepare any sauce pans or alternatively preparable glaze methods you’d like to use with your burger.
  3. Preheat your oven’s setting to roughly 350 degrees Fahrenheit.
  4. Meanwhile, line a baking sheet with parchment paper.
  5. Once room temperature is reached on nearby countertop areas, pour together spices such as paprika and ground black pepper into a bowl; add seasonings according to preference for boldness of flavor if desired.
  6. Dip one side of each patty into BBQ sauce mix or that prepared separately earlier before placing onto the lined baking sheet – you might fold edges up to prevent spillage.
  7. Place the tray in the oven and cook for ten minutes without flipping patties yet to allow proper heating throughout inside meat content .
  8. Check If browning has occurred around burger edges( sides exposed ), flip onto so opposite side cooks fully.. 9 Let patties cook (holding it steady) till see if they match their predefined time interval – usually varying no less than ten mins when predefining different thicknesses: e.g., six ounces would be standard for fully cooked point (with no pink). 10 After fully cooked duration achieved, take out turkey burgers from oven and place them gently atop a plate to highlight a nice personal burger bun.

Checking Doneness and Temperature

Checking if your Butterball turkey burgers are done is vital to prevent infections; hence, you should always ensure the meat has cooked all the way through before consuming. Achieving non-under-cooked status by treating doneness as criteria-filling, burgers that pulse with temperature aim to reach 165 Fahrenheit in every part of their interior areas.

While cutting your turkey burger is one method of checking for doneness, it wasn’t the most recommended – as this leads juices dissipate outside , leaving your patties dry. Instead, using a digital thermometer or accurate food temp probe are generally optimal when best gauging whether or not an appropriate level of safe doneness has been reached.

Serving Variations and Tips

There are myriad ways to serve your freshly cooked Butterball turkey burgers depending on preference. For those seeking classics-based ideas, we recommend adding lettuce leaves onto burger buns alongside additional flavor options like pickles, tomatoes pickled jalapenos/chopped avocado chunks or minced onions.

However, Butterball itself offers up “top picks” section recipe suggestions for heating up leftover meatballs in chili-topped quesadillas too!

In conclusion, cooking frozen Butterball turkey burgers in the oven is quick and convenient with little hassle once proper thawing is accomplished beforehand. By following these steps discussed earlier reinforced with different approaches listed here now – you can eat delicious home-made versions of these all-time favorite sandwiches like never before!


  1. Q: Do I need to thaw the frozen Butterball turkey burgers before cooking them in the oven? A: No, you can cook frozen Butterball turkey burgers directly in the oven. Make sure to preheat your oven to 375°F and follow the instructions on the packaging for cooking times.
  2. Q: Can I add any seasoning or toppings to my Butterball turkey burgers as they cook in the oven? A: Yes! Season your turkey burgers with salt, pepper, garlic powder, or any other of your favorite seasonings. You can also add some cheese or vegetables like onions or bell peppers on top of your burger before baking it.
  3. Q: How do I know when my Butterball turkey burgers are fully cooked in the oven? A: Use a meat thermometer to check that the internal temperature of your turkey burger is at least 165°F. This ensures that it is fully cooked and safe to eat. If you don’t have a meat thermometer, cut into the thickest part of the burger – if there’s no pink color inside and juices run clear, it’s done.
  4. Q: What sides would pair well with frozen Butterball turkey burgers baked in an oven? A: You can serve your Butterball turkey burgers on top of toasted buns with some lettuce, tomato, and pickles for a classic burger experience. Other recommended sides include sweet potato fries, roasted vegetables, or a mixed greens salad for a healthier option.


Similar Posts