Can I substitute applesauce for Greek yogurt in baking?

Baking is an important form of culinary art. It requires the use of various ingredients such as flour, sugar, eggs, fats, and liquids. However, when it comes to baking, one of the most essential ingredients is Greek yogurt. Its tangy flavor and creamy texture have made it a popular choice among bakers. But what if you don’t have Greek yogurt? Can you substitute it with applesauce? This article explores the possibility of using applesauce instead of Greek yogurt in baking.

Nutritional Differences Between Applesauce and Greek Yogurt

Before delving into the comparison between applesauce and Greek yogurt in terms of baking, it’s essential to understand their nutritional differences.

  • Calories: One cup (240 ml) of unsweetened applesauce contains around 100-120 calories, while one cup (240 ml) of non-fat plain Greek yogurt contains approximately 130-140 calories.
  • Fat content: Applesauce is fat-free, while Greek yogurt contains some amount of fat depending on the variety.
  • Protein content: One cup (240 ml) of non-fat plain Greek yogurt contains about 22-23 grams of protein per serving, while one cup (240 ml) of unsweetened applesauce has only 0.5 grams to 1 gram.
  • Carbohydrates: Applesauce has around 26 grams to 30gms carbs per serving size(100 grams). In contrast Greak Yogurt has around only 7 grams to 72 gram carbohydrates per serving size(200 grams.)

The benefit or drawback for each ingredient depends on the type and nature of the recipe that we want to implement:

Applesauce is low in fat and calories compared to Greek yogurt. Hence its usage plays a key role in health-conscious recipes where less calorie count is preferred.

Greek Yogurt’s high protein value acts as needful nourishment for people who are looking into building muscle or want to go keto.

What is Applesauce?

Applesauce is typically made by cooking and blending apples until they turn into pulp. It’s a common ingredient in baking, especially in recipes where you want to add moisture without using oil or butter. Unsweetened applesauce can often replace sugar in recipes, leading to a healthier version of baked goods.

The process of apple sauce making involves:

  1. Combine peeled, diced apples with a bit of water
  2. Cook the mixture over medium heat until the apples are soft
  3. Cool the mixture
  4. Puree the cooled mixture until smooth

Nowadays, some food brands also sell pre-packaged varieties including sweetened and unsweetened versions of apple sauce at local supermarkets.

What is Greek Yogurt?

Greek yogurt is a type of yogurt that has been strained to remove most of the liquid whey, lactose, and sugar, resulting in a thicker and creamier texture than traditional yogurt. Its acidic taste makes it an ideal component of many dips and sauces recipes all around the world.

It’s usually packed with nutritional value owing to its protein content (oleic amino acid, whey proteins) that acts as powerful sustenance for your muscles during workout routines.

Varieties available in stores include plain non-fat Greek yogurt, full-fat Greek yogurt flavored ones such as honey vanilla or fruit on top varieties at grocery stores worldwide.

Substitution Guidelines for Using Applesauce Instead of Greek Yogurt

When substituting applesauce for Greek yogurt in baked goods like cakes, cookies or breads one should make sure that :

The Proportions match

When substituting one ingredient for another important note to be remembered is that one should match their proportions accordingly based on recipe type. For instance if you need half-a-cup-size amount’s worth of yoghurt then measure out only half-a-cup size measured amount of applesauce instead.

Check the recipe requirement

It makes sense to check out the features of your recipe. Some recipes require a tangy taste, making Greek yogurt’s acidic flavor indispensable. Similarly, if your recipe needs a thicker consistency or stable moisture level, then applesauce should be avoided as it can considerably alter an original outcome.

Savoury dishes like dipping sauces, salad dressings etc tend to have flavorful ingredients already incorporated . Although Greek yoghurt may enhance that flavour even more , applesauce preferably fits the bill especially since it creates a thicker and creamier dip.

Substitution Guidelines for Using Greek Yogurt Instead of Applesauce

There still are times when one might feel needful of substituting Greek yogurt with applesauce. A notable example where this becomes essential is when baking particularly healthier cakes, muffins and bread which require low-fat versions when catering to health enthusiasts or sports persons.

Here are some guidelines on how to use Greek yogurt instead of applesauce:

  1. For baked goods where moisture content matters such as cake and muffin recipe varieties , use about 3/4 cup of non-fat plain Greek yogurt for every cup (240 ml) of applesauce required in the original recipe.
  2. When cooking savory dishes like dips or Salad dressings add few tablespoons only required from what was originally desired

Similarly, before going ahead with any substitution always thoroughly review your recipe instructions beforehand and then proceed accordingly .

Advantages and Disadvantages of Using Each Ingredient

Flavor alternatives : One major advantage with using both ingredients is that they provide different taste profiles depending upon recipe requirments: In comparison Apple sauce imparts natural sweetness whereas Greek yogurt tends to mesh better with salty condiments owing to its acidic flavor profile.

Additionally Apple Sauce in baking can result in softer + gooier textures but might not work well in all baked treats due to its ultra-moisture rich content. In contrast Greek yogurt can produce a denser product since it might not possess the water or sugar inclusion (depending on type) Applesauce has)

Recipe Examples Using Both Ingredients

To better examine both kinds of ingredients in baking, we compare some recipes showcasing their different aspects:

  1. Blueberry Muffin Recipe With Apple Sauce vs. BlueBerry Muffin Recipe WithGreekYogurt:

Apple sauce version recipe

  1. Baking Soda, Sugar, Flour, Salt have to be mixed 2.In another mixing bowl whisk egg,sugar,vanilla extract and apple sauce in. 3.Combine previously mix prepread mixture with dried flour mi separately. 4.Carefully fold the blueberries into the mix Bake for around sixteen mins time.

Greek Yogurt version recipe 1.Mix sugar,baking soda and flour together 2.On the freshly-used separate mixing bowl combine: whisk eggs,oil, vanilla and greek yogurt. 3.Combine dry ingredients (flour + sugar ingredients)then Fold blueberries separately Mix all components together thoroughly into muffin tins Bake at around three hundred fifty degrees for about twenty minutes

  1. Lemon Cake Recipe With Applesauce vs. Lemon Cake Recipe With Greek Yogurt

Apple sauce version recipe

-Mix lemon zest and juice thoroughly along with white sugar,nutmeg,flour mixture ,baking powder; brand-new mixing bowl used here . -Add in egg,milk,vanilla extract and applesauce into this while mostly stirring constantly

Bake for forty to forty-five minutes or until brownie like texture surface is obtained

Greek Yogurt Version Recipe

-Mix sugar and greek yogurt well before adding other dry ingredients like flour and baking powder. -Lemon juice,pureed apple sauce, vanilla extract are combined next along with egg and milk until the components are even

Bake at around 350 degrees for twenty-five minutes

  1. Comparison of Applesauce and Greek Yogurt Based Sauces for Salads:

Here’s how both ingredients work in creating a sauce:

Applesauce based recipe Combine together Applesauce, balsamic vinegar with orange zest prior to mixing maple syrup, pepper and salt after whisking them thoroughly

Greek Yogurt based recipe Start by whisking Greek yogurt,honey,vinegar, salt together .To get richer flavour try adding garlic or any other seasoning you often use.


The bottom line is that applesauce can be substituted but does not provide the same tangy flavor nor acidic side which makes valuble when making dips or dressings . This also doesn’t mean that you can only substitute using Greek yogurt always as some baked food recipes require dense outcome and lower-fat content.

While each ingredient has its own unique role in baking and cooking, substituting one for the other can provide exciting twists on some traditional favorites. Understanding what each ingredient offers nutritionally as well as texturally is crucial to determining if it will be a good substitute. Henceforth before making substitutions always check on the requirements of what your intended recipe factually needs so that these two amiable kitchen components also prove effective throughout your years long journey of experimenting with baking recipes !


Q: Can applesauce be used as a substitute for Greek yogurt in baking?

A: Yes, applesauce can be used as a substitute for Greek yogurt in baking. However, the consistency and taste may differ slightly.

Q: Can substituting applesauce for Greek yogurt affect the texture of baked goods?

A: Yes, using applesauce instead of Greek yogurt may result in a softer and more moist texture in baked goods.

Q: Will substituting Greek yogurt with applesauce impact the flavor of the recipe?

A: Substituting Greek yogurt with applesauce may make baked goods slightly sweeter and milder in flavor.

Q: Are there any other factors to consider when swapping out Greek yogurt for applesauce in baking?

A: It’s important to keep in mind that using applesauce instead of Greek yogurt may affect the overall acidity and leavening properties of the recipe. Adjustments may need to be made accordingly.

Similar Posts